29 points croes 2 hours ago 22 comments
jedberg 1 hour ago | parent
Turn myself into a moisture farmer if you will.
But then I wonder, would it be a problem if everyone did it? Would it cause humidity to drop in a bad way?
NewJazz 1 hour ago | parent
jawns 1 hour ago | parent
jedberg 26 minutes ago | parent
OneDeuxTriSeiGo 15 minutes ago | parent
roughly 18 minutes ago | parent
(To your point, it's almost impossible to imagine we'd be able to operate it at a scale that makes a genuine impact, but these are all chaotic systems and a couple percent here and there can compound to keep things on the right side of the phase shift.)
shagie 59 minutes ago | parent
And for the "the amount of times I change out 2 gallons of water from the dehumidifier in the basement in the summer"... there's a lot of moisture out there.
This is constrained by season. In the winter, its much easier to get to 0% humidity than it is in the summer.
https://tropic.ssec.wisc.edu/real-time/mtpw2/product.php?col... for the total precipitable water over North America. Through the midwest, it's in the 40-50mm range.
Consider XKCD's giant raindrop - https://what-if.xkcd.com/12/
> We’ll imagine our storm measures 100 kilometers on each side and has a high TPW content of 6 centimeters. This means the water in our rainstorm would have a volume of: 100km x 100km x 6cm = 0.6km^3
> That water would weigh 600 million tons (which happens to be about the current weight of our species). Normally, a portion of this water would fall, scattered, as rain—at most, 6 centimeters of it.
Change that to 4cm for current conditions... but that's a lot of water.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humidity#Relationship_between_...
That has a table of how much water at different humidity and temperature combinations. It's currently about 20 °C and that gives us 15.6 g/m^3.
... but there's an awful lot of air around.
This can also be complicated if you have trees or other vegetation around. The humidity at my parents place (fairly deep in the woods in farmland) is always much higher than it is if you go to the road (or in town).
https://extension.osu.edu/about/resources/corn-sweat-and-hum...
> Some research conducted by USDA Agricultural Research Service suggests that corn can contribute between 3,500 and 5,000 gallons of water per acre to the atmosphere over the course of one to two days. A typical pool contains 18,000 - 20,000 gallons.
...
So, it's complicated. Maybe, a little bit, depends on where you are.
chris_va 47 minutes ago | parent
Typical 50% RH at ground level is ~7g/kg air, air is roughly 1kg/m^3, so between the surface and the planetary boundary layer (let's say 1km) is about 7L of water per m^2 of surface. Moving along at ~3m/s means 21L/s passes by each meter of fence line.
PBL probably mixes after about 50km, so it takes ~5 hours to normalize after you pull out water at ~5 knot wind speed. If you want to not make a dent, means you can pull less than 1L per m^2 per hour, or about 8m^3 pear, which is about 8x the yearly requirement for farmland.
So, you can irrigate a farm and your neighbors would mostly be fine.
(math not checked)
RobGR 40 minutes ago | parent
As to your question, would it be a problem if everyone did it -- it depends obviously on your definition of "problem", but consider that most people doing this have no way to dispose of the water they take from the air except by putting it back in the air. It might increase regional power consumption, and smooth out nightly shifts in atmospheric humidity, but unless there is a new river running to the sea, the average atmospheric humidity will remain the same.
largbae 27 minutes ago | parent
LarsAlereon 17 minutes ago | parent
sublinear 1 hour ago | parent
pdonis 1 hour ago | parent
westurner 21 minutes ago | parent
You can install an aftermarket UVC light to sanitize to prevent mold in heat pumps, humidifiers, etc
OneDeuxTriSeiGo 7 minutes ago | parent
bix6 1 hour ago | parent
botanrice 1 hour ago | parent
dinkblam 48 minutes ago | parent
isn't below 40% "bad"?
Carrok 44 minutes ago | parent
ortusdux 40 minutes ago | parent
https://midwesthvacpro.com/what-should-indoor-humidity-be-a-...
MostlyStable 45 minutes ago | parent
I like it as a proof of concept, would love to see a more serious engineering effort to demonstrate what real world costs, durability, and aesthetics might look like (if significant portions of indoor walls are going to be covered in this stuff, it needs to be able to look decent).
westurner 25 minutes ago | parent
"Ask HN: Are there infrared wallpaper products in US markets?" (2025) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45444514 :
> /? infrared wallpaper heating : https://www.google.com/search?q=infrared+wallpaper+heating