155 points sandebert 1 month ago 117 comments
newprint 1 month ago | parent
dingensundso 1 month ago | parent
There are also still bombs and grenades in the rivers. There are some magnet fishing YouTube channels where you can occasionally see them pulling up stuff like that.
msdz 1 month ago | parent
My take (equally guessed): Among the literal rubble spread all over the cities, people constructing everything back up with whatever means possible couldn’t even recognize a mostly buried object as a bomb (instead of just more scrap from a collapsed building).
So less of an active decision to not deal with it, rather one out of necessity and/or not knowing about them, perhaps?
GolfPopper 1 month ago | parent
1. https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/1941/december/how...
usrusr 1 month ago | parent
I might be imagining this but I think that I have seen a report about some systematic effort to trace bomb dropping patterns in aerial images of the aftermath to find gaps in the pattern where something did not go off. But no idea how early or late after the war that happened (if it did happen). And those patterns will only show up for smaller bombs dropped in quantity, not for the big ones.
Merad 1 month ago | parent
jyounker 1 month ago | parent
trencedamp 1 month ago | parent
bell-cot 1 month ago | parent
A 500 lbs bomb falling from altitude can bury itself a fair ways in soil. Most of its fellow bombs will have good fuses - and with the mess they make, it would take some careful excavation in just the right spot to find the dud bomb. (Or, maybe it fell in a patch of overgrown brush in a park, or in a river, or a farmer's pond, or ...)
And with the scale at which Germany was bombed in WWII, there was nothing remotely resembling the resources to carefully excavate all the myriad square miles where dud bombs might have fallen. Either during the war, or after.
scyzoryk_xyz 1 month ago | parent
Unexploded Soviet ordnance - insane how much of it was dropped and buried in the rubble to this day. You're right though - weird to think that nobody would notice, but so much Europe was turned to rubble at that time. These things got turned to unrecognizable rusty mush after a few decades.
Pretty sure it's also an excuse to keep the bomb squad and evacuation procedures in practice. These things are pretty routine, there is no fear or panic. IThey just diffuse and take the thing away to some military range to dispose of it.
lukan 1 month ago | parent
Definitely not in this eastern part of germany where I live. Every major construction needs to check for bombs, but it also happens randomly that a excavator finds a bomb.
There were just a looot of bombs dropped. (And they don't always move it, often it is too rusty also to defuse and then controlled explosion if the surroundings allow it (they use lots of water bags on top, witnessed it once))
cucumber3732842 1 month ago | parent
A farmer or construction worker (or at least one outside of Germany or any other culture famed for incessant rule following) only needs to watch the bomb squad guy rip a shell out of the ground with a shovel and no specific care given once before they realize it's best if they just do that damn job themselves and avoid the hassle.
lukan 1 month ago | parent
Because that can happen. And if they know, it still can go wrong.
From TFA:
"In June 2010, three bomb-disposal experts in Göttingen, Germany, were killed by a 500kg American bomb found beneath the site of a new sports arena. "
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/jun/02/germany-bomb-w...
ceejayoz 1 month ago | parent
Do you apply this logic to surgery, engineering, etc.?
"The expert makes it look easy, therefore it must be easy."
cucumber3732842 1 month ago | parent
ceejayoz 1 month ago | parent
watwut 1 month ago | parent
cucumber3732842 1 month ago | parent
Regardless, farmers across the EU pull thousands of tons of shells out of the ground every spring. They, as a demographic, have infinitely (because anything is infinitely more than zero) more experience than some out of touch office workers who read the official recommendations the local bomb squad writes up and screech about the fact that nobody follows them.
watwut 1 month ago | parent
Frankly, the only out of touch person here is you - likely office worker who imagine that all farmers are irrational macho men. And someone who genuinely thinks that if some safety rules are skipped for comfort, then surely most will try to hit the bomb with random equipment to see whether it blows.
cucumber3732842 1 month ago | parent
The farmer or backhoe operator or whatever does not typically know there is a shell or whatever there until after it's been hit with machinery. This is not the year 1100. People are generally not engaging the ground with hand tools. They are engaging it with buckets and implements that do their work in bulk. When you encounter anything man made it's usually only after you've moved it about. "Hey that's an odd looking rock, oh wait that's a shell". Once it's already been hit by your bucket or whatever the sensible thing to do is put it down somewhere far away, call it in, and keep doing whatever you were doing in the meantime.
thi2 1 month ago | parent
21asdffdsa12 1 month ago | parent
Those areas where moon craters at the end of the war. But by then logistics where decentralized, all those last days last ditch products, where made in underground facilities or small village smith factories. Effectively they bombed a bomb disposal pit..
gmueckl 1 month ago | parent
johannes1234321 1 month ago | parent
That was a quite impressive experience. Windows in the surrounding area broke and straw, which they used to damlen the shockwave, caught fire and was thrown around.
hezxks 1 month ago | parent
Link Aerial image: https://gdi.berlin.de/viewer/main/?MAPS={"center":[390416.44...
Link example oblique aerial image: https://gdi.berlin.de/data/luftbild_1954_sl/pictures/1954_sl...
billypilgrim 1 month ago | parent
ks1723 1 month ago | parent
https://www.im.nrw/system/files/media/document/file/jahresst...
In 2024, 182 bombs with 50kg or more were removed, 12 of which were detonated on-site.
OoooooooO 1 month ago | parent
It just became a routine.
thi2 1 month ago | parent
I came across this paper last week. It was quite an interesting read, it is in german but I assume translations will work fine.
throwawayffffas 1 month ago | parent
cogogo 1 month ago | parent
smackeyacky 1 month ago | parent
robk 1 month ago | parent
iJohnDoe 1 month ago | parent
coldcity_again 1 month ago | parent
A very worthwhile watch. I come back to it every few years.
helsinkiandrew 1 month ago | parent
weinzierl 1 month ago | parent
My parents were around the age of the children in the series during WW II in Germany and what they recounted matched how the children experienced the time pretty well.
rjmunro 1 month ago | parent
throwaway270925 1 month ago | parent
Steve44 1 month ago | parent
It was still in fresh memory for a lot of people, broadcast 25 years after the end of WW2, I think it got the feeling over very well.
pbowyer 1 month ago | parent
pseudohadamard 1 month ago | parent
corint 1 month ago | parent
AntonTrollback 1 month ago | parent
bell-cot 1 month ago | parent
BTW, Europe has similar problems with dud artillery shells, old minefields, etc. And it's not just WWII, nor just Germany. The most infamous is probably https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Zone_(World_War_I)
AntonTrollback 1 month ago | parent
Imagine a place like Afghanistan. I assume neither USSR nor USA records are accessible for the people there. Their landmine issue is just too sad
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-3205978/Pictured-harr...
stickfigure 1 month ago | parent
kjs3 1 month ago | parent
The money quote is:
Conventionally the air forces designated as "the target area" a
circle having a radius of 1000 feet around the aiming point of
attack . While accuracy improved during the war, Survey studies
show that, in the over-all, only about 20% of the bombs aimed at
precision targets fell within this target area.
I went down a rabbit hole and researched this a bit when we built an EU datacenter a couple of decades ago.tom89999 1 month ago | parent
Translated with DeepL.com (free version)
Animats 1 month ago | parent
21asdffdsa12 1 month ago | parent
folbec 1 month ago | parent
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zone_rouge
(to top that some ammo dumps were simply dumped in holes in the ground at the end of the war and are slowly diffusing there toxic compounds via under ground rivers)
21asdffdsa12 1 month ago | parent
pjc50 1 month ago | parent
Animats 1 month ago | parent
Here's the sign at the SL-1 site, which is not a deep burial.[2]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onkalo_spent_nuclear_fuel_repo...
justin66 1 month ago | parent
OkayPhysicist 1 month ago | parent
Fun fact: One of the best analogs available for phosgene that's been sitting in cold water for a hundred years is Wintergreen DOTS candy, if you can keep the engineers and military brass from eating all of them.
hommelix 1 month ago | parent
PetitPrince 1 month ago | parent
SiempreViernes 1 month ago | parent
pseudohadamard 1 month ago | parent
thorin 1 month ago | parent
roryirvine 1 month ago | parent
https://www.rafmuseum.org.uk/research/collections/remotec-wh...
They were a fairly common sight on the streets of Belfast in the 1980s/90s, where carrying out controlled explosions on unattended vehicles proved to be a remarkably effective deterrent against illegal parking...
robotmay 1 month ago | parent
mrlonglong 1 month ago | parent
GJim 1 month ago | parent
1.4kt of explosive sat in the Thames Eastury, 35 miles down river from central London, that nobody knows how to get rid of.
"it was determined that if the wreck of Richard Montgomery exploded, it would throw a 300 metres (980 feet)-wide column of water and debris nearly 3,000 metres (9,800 feet) into the air and generate a wave 5 metres (16 feet) high. Almost every window in Sheerness (population circa 20,000) would be broken and buildings would be damaged by the blast."
TeMPOraL 1 month ago | parent
Just evacuate the people and blow it up, accepting that it'll inconvenience a lot of folks and the national budget even more, but will also briefly revitalize the local economy, as every contractor there is will maximize the opportunity to suck out the funds set aside for repairing buildings damaged in the explosion - and make sure to record the disposal itself from every possible angle, with most expensive cameras government can buy, as selling clips of it to the media industry would be a licensing goldmine and recoup some of the costs.
Hell, turn it into a spectator event, and tourists coming to see it may just pay for the whole thing.
kakacik 1 month ago | parent
Say 50 million budget. Of course red tape, bureaucracy and just laziness/incompetence of state bureaucrats would make such budget balloon and drag for a decade or two, but it should be doable.
manarth 1 month ago | parent
If 15m of water can't contain the blast, adding concrete or similar is more likely to add solid projectiles to the explosion than diminish the force of the blast.
bluGill 1 month ago | parent
Note that I'm not claiming the above is a good plan. Just that it is better than a dome.
kbelder 1 month ago | parent
petesergeant 1 month ago | parent
TeMPOraL 1 month ago | parent
BoxOfRain 1 month ago | parent
pja 1 month ago | parent
One of those times when you do have to ask “who exactly thought this was a good idea?”
cucumber3732842 1 month ago | parent
mnw21cam 1 month ago | parent
M95D 1 month ago | parent
dnemmers 1 month ago | parent
https://www.munirem.com/recovery-and-neutralization-of-dynam...
thejazzman 1 month ago | parent
ceejayoz 1 month ago | parent
> When the condition of the munitions was originally assessed there was concern that copper azide, an extremely sensitive explosive, would be produced through reaction between lead azide and copper from fuze components (lead azide would react with water vapour, rather than liquid water, to form hydrazoic acid, which could react with copper in the detonating cap to form copper azide).
> An investigation by New Scientist magazine in 2004, based partly on government documents released that year, concluded that the cargo was still deadly, and could be detonated by a collision, an attack, or even shifting of the cargo in the tide. The deterioration of the bombs was so severe that they could explode spontaneously.
bluGill 1 month ago | parent
We are also hoping that future technology will figure out a better way to handle this.
TeMPOraL 1 month ago | parent
bluGill 1 month ago | parent
dmurray 1 month ago | parent
This makes sense if you can tolerate some chance of the whole thing blowing up, but you'd still prefer not to replace all those windows.
throwawayffffas 1 month ago | parent
Oarch 1 month ago | parent
I saw them while still attached earlier this summer - very spooky, like being next to a potentially active volcano.
tim333 1 month ago | parent
sandworm101 1 month ago | parent
The 2020 Beirut explosion involved 2,750 tonnes of ammonium nitrite which exploded with a force equivalent to 1,100 tonnes of TNT.
The SS Richard Montgomery sank with 1,400 tonnes of explosives, of a variety of types, some of which could be more powerful than TNT.
euroderf 1 month ago | parent
lp92 1 month ago | parent
m463 1 month ago | parent
tinthedev 1 month ago | parent
I remember being astounded by how the water "amplifies" the explosions - so while a hand grenade blast is very dangerous on the surface, under the sea it becomes far more horrific prospect, due to the water transferring the blast more efficiently. Nerve wracking stuff, when you're thinking about diving down there - imagining that a bomb dozens of meters away could pulverize you.
Still pretty rare, thankfully. I applaud the diver bomb disposal squads - some of the most dangerous work there is.
vova_hn2 1 month ago | parent
Curiously, it is exactly the opposite in many video games. In video games water often protects you from the explosion. I wonder, where did this trope came from...
bluGill 1 month ago | parent
My guess is water protects from nuclear radiation and they get confused. Anyone else want to guess where the trope came from?
manarth 1 month ago | parent
If you're outside the water, the density difference between air and water acts to diffuse the shockwave.
Water is a really good absorbent of explosive energy (as long as you're not also in the same water).
tinthedev 1 month ago | parent
bell-cot 1 month ago | parent
The torpedo defense systems in the most advanced WWII battleships & carriers were about 5 layers thick: sea (may contain enemy mines & torpedoes) | empty compartment (air gap) | ballast/fuel tank | air gap | ballast/fuel tank | yet another air gap | important stuff (engine rooms, powder magazines, whatever)
And to be reasonably effective, each air & fluid layer needs a certain thickness - which scales roughly with the size of the explosive charge.
close04 1 month ago | parent
In some places bomb disposal technicians are only allowed on the job for a limited time. Then they move to the "back seat" and consult or assist from far away. Because with years of knowledge and experience comes the kind of confidence that doesn't apply well to unknown devices rusting in the ground for close to a century. Misplaced confidence is dangerous.
Does it work the same way in the UK?
KineticLensman 1 month ago | parent
Probably not. The article mentions two active bomb disposal soldiers whose rank is Major or higher, and a colonel who oversees operations. This seems like a standard military career progression, not specific to the EOD regiment. In the armoured infantry, for example, a company commander (i.e. a Major) might still fight as a dismount, delegating a sergeant to stay in their vehicle to command it.
Also note that in the British Army, soldiers of all trades often move jobs every couple of years, sometime returning to a particular organisation but now with a higher rank.
jillesvangurp 1 month ago | parent
It was slightly funny because I configured my phone to use a weird chipmunk voice to read stuff out loud apparently (not a feature I use) and it actually started reading out the message. Big WTF. moment until I figured out. Grabbed my attention though and it was the first real alarm I've received. We get a practice alarm message every few months.
Steve44 1 month ago | parent
I think it closed for a few years but seems to have reopened. Hopefully it's still got the eclectic collections and the knowledgable staff.
One of the many interesting exhibits was some pipeline and information about Operation Pluto; that was for getting fuel over to France following D-Day.
https://romneymarshhistory.co.uk/pluto
https://www.rmwcollection.co.uk/
https://aviationmuseum.eu/Blogvorm/brenzett-aeronautical-mus...
askvictor 1 month ago | parent
silvester23 1 month ago | parent
alexpotato 1 month ago | parent
This is a great vote for documentation and keeping records.
You never know piece of trivial information may prove vital down the road. You also don't know how long in the future a current piece of critical information will stay critical.
hommelix 1 month ago | parent
When our house was built, the water company workers spend a day digging on the side of the road to search for the fresh water pipe, but they could not find it. A retired neighbor walked by and told them, that the road has been straightened and one bend removed 10 years ago. As their map was not updated, the actual pipe was 5m from where they were digging. Trivial piece of information missing.
alexpotato 1 month ago | parent
I was recently reading Malcolm Gladwell's new book about gun violence.
One thing that really stood out:
Most European countries have MORE police per capita than the US.
kelnos 1 month ago | parent
The per-capita number is only one part of the puzzle. This is one of the annoying things about Gladwell's work: he writes breathlessly about statistics like this, but often fails to put them in broader context, when that context matters.
goodcanadian 1 month ago | parent
dwd 1 month ago | parent
An unexploded shell from a WW2-era live firing range was found the other day in my area - far from any war zone.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-10-04/wwii-shell-detonated-...
egorfine 1 month ago | parent