8 points nyxtom 32 minutes ago 5 comments

nyxtom 32 minutes ago | parent

I know this is old but it seems that we've somehow moved on from the fact that we're in a modern Alexandria moment where rare text is being destroyed

pfdietz 24 minutes ago | parent

I doubt any rare valuable book is being destroyed. If a book were valuable, it would make sense to scan it non-destructively. This is especially the case for old rare books that are long out of copyright; the copyright motivation for not keeping the original copy around does not exist.

The books being destroyed as so worthless they're bought in bulk and were destined for junking anyway, like the 600 million books that are destroyed each year just in the US. At least as pulp they can contribute something of slight value.

Here's a way these old supposed valuable books can get a new life. Go wild! Prices start at $12.99 per linear foot. This clearly demonstrates the value society assigns to these precious rectangular prisms of inked cellulose.

https://booksbythefoot.com/

I have a sneaking suspicion the whole tempest-in-a-teapot was astroturfed by publishers who were miffed at the courts looking favorably on scanning for AI training.

Lithuanian 28 minutes ago | parent

Does it matter much? Books are digital anyway and every book has a copy of itself somewhere in the world. It's not like something irreplaceable is being destroyed.

rolph 2 minutes ago | parent

[delayed]

pfdietz 27 minutes ago | parent

Yes, we are, because it's a non-problem.

m4rtink 4 minutes ago | parent

All books are sacred. Anyone who destroys books is a criminal and should be punished hard, ideally to make an example, preventing more books from being destroyed.