21 points surprisetalk 2 days ago 21 comments

londons_explore 3 hours ago | parent

I disagree with this guy.

I have a pile of both zinc-carbon and alkaline batteries, and a whole host of devices round my house that take them (TV remote, CO alarm, fake PS5 controller, laser level, doorbell, weighing scales, Polaroid camera, flashlights, bike lights, heating system valves, thermometer).

All devices work with the alkalines. But some devices won't work at all with the zinc-carbon batteries, and others have a comedically short battery life (eg. My weighing scales start to weigh wrong after just a few days on a zinc battery).

Overall, it just isn't worth the hassle to save a few cents on a battery.

And I don't have trouble with either of them leaking.

xattt 3 hours ago | parent

Alec “paretomaxxes” his recent topics because it’s what apparently grabs eyeballs.

As a discerning consumer, you still have the agency to pick batteries that work for you. The main selling point is to give zinc-carbons a try if you have a low-power device you rarely use.

However, a lot of times you just grab what’s at hand (probably alkaline) as a trip to the dollar store for that specific battery type doesn’t make sense.

srgb_vs_cmyk 2 hours ago | parent

I see heaps of discounted Kodak zinc-carbon battery blister packs, and they are without any doubt, shortest lasting batteries I ever encountered. I consider even the TV remote a too demanding task for them.

londons_explore 3 hours ago | parent

Not sure if it's the case in the USA, but here in the UK it seems to be that AAA and AA batteries cost exactly the same, and that offends me. Why should I pay the same for half the storage capacity? Is it price fixing?

Steve44 3 hours ago | parent

I'm going to speculate based on my experience with manufacturing & distribution.

The physical process to make a AA and a AAA is the same. The same machinery, using the same range of slightly difference size parts, and pretty much the same number of units per hour produced.

The storage & distribution will also be very similar so much of those costs will be the same. Yes the AAA is smaller and lighter so there will be some cost differences, but it's not like an AAA vs D.

Much of the final cost will be in the retail side of the business where the cost of processing a sale of AA and a sale of AAA is the same.

I do agree with you though, it's a little grating.

Skwid 3 hours ago | parent

I think more likely it's that the cost of materials is a pitiful fraction of the total cost. It takes just as many workers and machines to make a smaller battery, and they travel in the same lorry to the shop

selcuka 3 hours ago | parent

But you can fit more AAAs into the same lorry.

Also they don't cost the same in Australia, for example. I've also checked amazon.co.uk and they don't cost the same there either (£18.71 vs £11.20 for Amazon Basics 100-pack).

monegator 3 hours ago | parent

QRD?

ta8903 2 hours ago | parent

People don't use AA/AAA cells for high power appliances these days, so most people will be fine with replacing alkaline batteries with zinc-carbon ones, which are cheaper and potentially last longer/leak less.

eternityforest 2 hours ago | parent

Alkaline batteries are best used for things where the shelf life is the limiting factor.

Can zinc carbon sit for 20 years, running at a few milliamps for five minutes once a month, or for a few seconds s few times a day?

4gotunameagain 3 hours ago | parent

Clickbait, alkaline batteries are not obsolete.

Even if we accept his claim that all modern devices that take disposable AA/AAA batteries draw very little current, there are still so many old devices in use.

russdill 3 hours ago | parent

And for those devices, there are better choices (as discussed) than alkaline.

4gotunameagain 3 hours ago | parent

There are better choices if you assume I can recharge.

On a trip, you can buy alkaline batteries anywhere

haddr 3 hours ago | parent

One argument that is wrong in the video: yes batteries are the same shape but some cheap brands basically put there less battery cells or basically less materials making those batteries less durable. I found out once by simply weighting such batteries against other more durable and the difference was ~ 30%. So it is still important to choose wisely even within the same class (e.g alkaline)

russdill 3 hours ago | parent

The video specifically discusses that one way you can usually tell that a battery is Zinc-Carbon vs Alkaline is because it's lighter and that batteries are often poorly/mislabled.

adrian_b 2 hours ago | parent

"Zinc-carbon battery" is a very inappropriate name.

Batteries are correctly named by the substances that react chemically with each other, providing energy.

Both the "zinc-carbon" batteries and the alkaline batteries are correctly named "zinc-maganese batteries".

They do not differ in the chemical reactants, they differ only in the nature of the electrolyte through which the ionic current passes, which is saline for "zinc-carbon batteries" (i.e. based on a solution of ammonium chloride) and alkaline for the "alkaline batteries (i.e. based on a solution of caustic potash).

The carbon electrode in the "zinc-carbon batteries" is inert and it does not matter for the chemical reactions. It just must be an electric conductor that is not corroded by the electrolyte. Carbon is the cheapest suitable material, but you could replace it with expensive materials, e.g. with platinum, and the battery would function exactly in the same way.

Alkaline batteries have higher performance mainly because they have a lower internal electric resistance, because both the electrolyte has a higher conductivity and the carbon electrode is replaced by a steel electrode with higher conductivity, which is possible because it is not corroded by the alkaline electrolyte.

yread 2 hours ago | parent

Li-ion usbc rechargeable are a nice concept, but the price needs to come down a lot. Here they cost 20 eur for a 4 pack. That's the same as 20.000 mAh powerbank with PD.

eternityforest 2 hours ago | parent

Li ion will calendar age itself to unusability before alkaline runs out, in the kind of nanopower applications that disposable batteries are actually good for.

RetroTechie 2 hours ago | parent

Stopped buying disposable batteries years ago & never looked back. Have seen too many devices over time whose battery contacts were nuked due to leaking alkalines.

It used to be that NiMH's weren't good for long-standby, low power applications like TV remotes, digital clocks & the like. That hasn't been true since the introduction of low self-discharge ("precharged", "stay charged" etc) NiMH's a decade+ ago (pro tip: Eneloop Lite is perfect for such uses).

Some people claim that NiMH's lower output voltage is a problem. That's nonsense: practically any device designed to take AA/AAA will work down to ~1.1...1.0V, at which point NiMH is empty. At higher current draw, NiMH's tend to compare favourably against alkalines.

It does pay to invest in a good charger, and avoid no-name brands though. In order of personal preference: Eneloop, japanese-MADE like Sanyo/Panasonic or Fujitsu, then respected brands like Duracell. Don't bother with non-LSD cells, and cheapo brands aren't worth the risk of quality/performance issues.

Most people who don't opt for rechargeables, base their opinion on experience with NiMHs from 20y ago, crappy chargers, outdated info, or have money to burn & are simply lazy. Even that last point is questionable: I consider it easier to just pop a few cells in a charger & use, than head off to a store to buy disposables.

For consumer uses, alkaline has no place in modern society imho. Technology has advanced, rechargeables are cheap, good & easy now.

eternityforest 2 hours ago | parent

The important thing to note is that a "good charger" doesn't just mean from a trusted brand, it has to charge the batteries individually.

Otherwise, if it charges two in series, and you have a device that needs three, you'll probably eventually mismatch the charge levels.

If you ruin a battery it will be hard to find the bad one without a tester, and your charger won't help you if it can't measure individual cells...

I still prefer alkaline for anything that only needs replacing every 15 years though. I use NiMh in my mouse but alkaline in things I use once a year for a few minutes, like my pocket multimeter.

RetroTechie 1 hour ago | parent

> The important thing to note is that a "good charger" doesn't just mean from a trusted brand, it has to charge the batteries individually

Yep. Individual cell charging, using a proper delta-V method that detects when a cell is full, and per-cell indication of what's happening.

That way it's just "pop in some cells, wait, use" with 0 worries about state-of-charge before they go in (or mixing empty & half-empty ones. They all come out equally charged).

Chargers which do constant-current + timer cutoff are crap, that will overcharge & destroy your cells.