6 points negura 2 hours ago 9 comments

davydm 42 minutes ago | parent

Pretty sure AI can adapt to a simple substitution cypher.

tocs3 42 minutes ago | parent

I asked ChatGPT (a year or two ago) if it could read my message. I used a simple substitution cypher to ask the question and not only did it reply yes but used the same substitution cypher to reply. I wonder how useful this sort of thing would actually be to keep things secure. It might fool an old time bot but would an LLM even notice?

I think it is a neat idea and may try to spend a little time with it in the next few days.

umvi 41 minutes ago | parent

Breaking the clipboard is just annoying for users. If they want the text they will screenshot + OCR

negura 24 minutes ago | parent

In that case you could combine it also with https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50500682

But the goal here is mainly to stop crawlers (or at least add enough adversarial cost).

artico_chewy 40 minutes ago | parent

Claude:

It’s an Atbash cipher (A↔Z, B↔Y, etc.). Decoded:

“This is some sensitive text that only humans can read”

Claude then proceeded to insult the cipher.

xscott 24 minutes ago | parent

Similar reply with low-tier ChatGPT. It even used the double headed arrows - maybe they're distilling :-)

BobbyTables2 12 minutes ago | parent

I also find Claude can really throw shade, but in an extremely understated, subtle “British” style. Maybe it explains the “-our” spellings of words like behaviour.

negura 10 minutes ago | parent

Very possibly the example and explanation on that page (originally published 11 years ago) has been crawled when AI was trained. In my tests it's unable to crack it when you reorder the alphabet using other than a simple reverse rule.

Qxuk qkcqlwlfk wkow wdjw xcir dmujcq umqw gk jgik wx ykjh

QMAZFLCXBRHWEKTDYGONIVPJUS

Besides, it's likely that the average crawler has naive filters for gibberish and would give up early on your content, rather than wasting tokens trying to decrypt it.

spdustin 4 minutes ago | parent

And also inaccessible texts. As in, text that is not able to be read by accessibility tools such as VoiceOver.