12 points Betelbuddy 42 minutes ago 9 comments

smallerize 29 minutes ago | parent

What I want to know is - what are they all doing all the time?

luckydata 20 minutes ago | parent

"just"?

bradleybuda 20 minutes ago | parent

The GDP of Michigan is $734B. The combined cloud computing revenues of Google, AWS, and Microsoft (which make up a large fraction of this datacenter work, though not all of it) are $290B. So yes, we should expect the power usage of these things to be in the same order of magnitude.

shimman 10 minutes ago | parent

No, I wouldn't expect that at all. Google, AWS, and MSFT do not care about helping society. They do not care about making sure children get a good public education. They do not care that workers are treated with dignity. These three can't even bother to hire Americans for jobs in America. They just care about making money.

The state of Michigan provides more value for humanity than those three companies easily.

In fact we should explicitly tax those companies to provide free public school lunches, universal childcare, and universal college/secondary/vocational training programs.

For fun, look at what these three companies are explicitly paying for their data center build out and look at the cost of what it would cost to provide every American school child free lunch.

These companies are sick and should be justly destroyed.

richwater 7 minutes ago | parent

> should be justly destroyed

Ah, the truth emerges. The smokescreen about taxes, appeal to emotion, etc are all just rooted in that you want to seize and destroy companies you personally disagree of.

djeastm 15 minutes ago | parent

Somewhat related: Data centers used 22 percent of Ireland's metered electricity in 2024, up from 5 percent in 2015.

https://www.cso.ie/en/releasesandpublications/ep/p-dcmec/dat...

Silamoth 8 minutes ago | parent

Always good to see more hard data on this topic! I’d be curious to play with their dataset. I toyed around with doing some data center research a couple months ago. My vision was to compare data center counts and population densities near data centers built before and after the dawn of LLMs. And do some other stuff. But I had trouble finding reliable data on where data centers are located (some lists exist, but they’re not perfect, so I was doing manual validation) and when they were built (permitting and whatnot provided decent bounds). In the end, there was too much manual work. I didn’t feel like doing that all weekend for several weekends in a row, and I have a day job to worry about during the week. Though this might be motivation to look back at this and do some automation…

Regarding the actual result, I’m appalled but not surprised (though obviously it’s good to have concrete data). We environmentalists having been raising this concern for at least a year. More people are catching on - this seems to have helped the Blue Wave this election season. But a lot of tech bros still don’t get it, particularly here on HN. Maybe this will help change some minds.