17 points rawgabbit 2 hours ago 15 comments

cmiles8 1 hour ago | parent

The H1B program has been heavily abused for years. While there has been some collateral damage with the current crackdown, it’s pretty hard to defend what was going on in this space prior to the crackdown.

jcarmackdaddy 1 hour ago | parent

Well the indentured servants that need to compete with China on an industrial scale need to come from somewhere. It just turns out the program importing them is based on a system of caste & race, and achieving goals isn't necessarily a part of bilking people.

Also, pointing this out tends to be a form of noticing the emperor is indeed, not wearing clothes...

thesmtsolver2 11 minutes ago | parent

> indentured servants

Highest paying industry worldwide.

> caste & race

Yep, we all know of elite leetcode interviews around caste.

/s

kevin_thibedeau 39 minutes ago | parent

The one thing they need to do above all else is ban body shops from sponsoring. That is the core of the abuse and they'll never touch it.

esalman 46 minutes ago | parent

The tech outages are definitely not the result of discouraging talents from participating in US workforce. /S

thinkybrewster 14 minutes ago | parent

definitely not! There is no company more committed to quality and profit sharing than Microsoft

Calc13 45 minutes ago | parent

It would be interesting to see three other data points along side with the timeline of these actions. - The pace of job migration permanently into eastern Europe, India or elsewhere. - The drop in Graduate and PhD enrollment from abroad. - Direction of wage changes of tech workers in the US.

zanderwohl 30 minutes ago | parent

I agree that a lot needs to change about the H-1B program, but I don't love how much of it has come from executive orders and worse: just offhand statements that drive employers into anxiety and uncertainty. Uncertainty is just the worst thing for the market (and my own salary prospects). The $100,000 fee felt like it was rolled out in jolts. Who was affected? Who was exempt?

At least with laws passed, we see it coming from a long way away. IMO, congress should reduce the powers the executive branch can just wield on this or that, and set the agenda, rather than letting the agenda be set by the president every 4/8 years.

dmitrygr 10 minutes ago | parent

1. "I agree a lot need to change"

2. "we need make sure to take power away from $entity_changing it and give it to $entity_who_has_had_decades_and_fixed_nothing"

3. ???

4. profit

how do you expect change if you keep asking for the entity who has had ample time and fixed nothing to have more power?

throwaway919233 27 minutes ago | parent

Letting the executive play with policy seems like a wild overreach. I wish congress limited those powers.

>Among the highest lottery entrants in FY2026 were Cognizant, Infosys, and Tata, which submitted 100%, 91%, and 95% fewer registrations in FY2027, respectively

Very effective in bringing down abuse. It doesn't comment on the impact of fields where immigrants are needed and they can't afford the $100k

thinkybrewster 19 minutes ago | parent

> It doesn't comment on the impact of fields where immigrants are needed

uhhh "needed", what would that look like?

darthoctopus 2 minutes ago | parent

universities, despite being cap-exempt, are not exempted from this fee. This has basically killed academic hiring of foreign academics (i.e. the ability for American universities to brain-drain foreign ones as they historically have).

splicebot 11 minutes ago | parent

Congress is STILL free to limit those powers. They always have been.

Suppafly 4 minutes ago | parent

>It doesn't comment on the impact of fields where immigrants are needed and they can't afford the $100k

Why worry about fields that don't exist?

diogenescynic 18 minutes ago | parent

This is the first thing I can genuinely remember in nearly my entire lifetime that a president has done that directly impacts most Americans in a positive, universal, bipartisan way. Too bad Congress ignored, and actively aided and abetted, this abuse for decades. Trump has been horrible in a lot of ways, but even a broken clock is right occasionally and I'll give him credit on this one. And democrats would have cowered and wilted before ever even doing this--they have no backbone to have any sense of national civic duty to protect actual Americans.