46 points hn_acker 4 hours ago 40 comments

dasil003 1 hour ago | parent

Do you want to be right or do you want to be effective? As much as the article tries to claim it's not setting up a "moral purity test", that's what these sorts of hypothetical conundrums do. This is the exact type of privileged navel gazing that cause Democrats to lose the plot on what working class people in America had actually been experiencing, opening the door to much more blatantly obvious corruption and grift from Trump.

It's important for social and political movements to scope their ambitions to not alienate potential allies with overcooked positions. Build coalitions as well, but do so opportunistically where you have a chance to actually win something and move the needle. Don't craft your charter to already be so exclusive out of the gate that you only appeal to the like-minded fringe. You want to do something for software freedom? Talk about John Deere, not imaginary enslaved open source coders.

bemtevi 1 hour ago | parent

> Their argument was that in the context of Emacs development, the only thing that matters is the quality of the code being contributed

This is something I've never agreed with. One part of open-source is to have some principle that is rooted in ethics, but how can you be true to that when you ignore other ethical dimension that can't be separated from the traditional open-source one?

I don't think the only think that matters is the quality of the code. It's a myopic viewpoint. The reasoning behind having open code in the first place matters as well, which was that one person was trying to take advantage of another in a way that seemed intuitively unfair. LLMs do the same thing. If you fight for only one ideal but reject another parallel one for convenience, then I believe the first stands for nothing at all.

skybrian 1 hour ago | parent

Over 20,000 people have contributed to the Linux kernel and there are around 2,000 contributors per release. How can it viable to judge whether each contributor is overall a good person?

One way to make moderation practical is by limiting the moderators’ jurisdiction to the things they have direct evidence for. For example, presumably the moderators of Hacker News limit their scope to what people do in Hacker News, rarely going beyond that to looking at behavior in other forums or what people do in their personal lives.

Similarly, moderators of an open source project could mostly limit their scope to what people do when interacting with the project’s systems.

bemtevi 1 hour ago | parent

You can't judge whether everyone is a good person. But you can put in basic rules that obviously go against immoral behaviour. Not everyone obeys the "no shirt in the shopping mall" rule but it's there and it's a good one.

Many open source projects have a Code of Conduct, for a reason. And people who break it are called out. Many open source projects are anti-AI as well like YT-DLP and Asahi Linux. It can be done and easily without much fuss.

antonymoose 1 hour ago | parent

> "no shirt in the shopping mall" rule but it's there and it's a good one.

Hey man you put it off the beach and I just want an Orange Julius what’s the problem man?

bemtevi 58 minutes ago | parent

Hahaha. Good one.

interroboink 54 minutes ago | parent

Some interesting overlap here with the "What Color Are Your Bits"[1] article. Check it out if you haven't already (:

It describes some of the communication mismatches when people talk about IP issues. "Lawyers see color" but computer scientists don't.

[1] https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23

p4bl0 1 hour ago | parent

If you read French, or can use a translator, I wrote about this paradoxical approach of the free software movement a few years back: https://p4bl0.net/post/2022/11/Paradoxe-libriste-et-logiciel...

jraph 58 minutes ago | parent

I think you are discussing a related but quite different topic here (worth discussing, for sure, but I'm taking issue with your phrasing "I wrote about this paradoxical approach of the free software movement").

The post discusses about how the code gets written collectively, yours discusses what the code can be used for. Yours discusses potentially desirable limitations on freedom 0 (and indeed, contradicts the accepted definition of free software - that's not a judgement, it's a fact). The other post discusses being more demanding on how free software is made in a way that doesn't contradict the free software definition, and (that's where both are indeed related I think) whether we as maintainers should have our shoulders to the software freedom wheel a bit less and consider more the bigger human freedom picture (and I guess my phrasing gives away what I think about this).

Restricting freedom 0 is tempting but perilous and can have consequences you have not anticipated and might not like. One can totally agree with your goal (avoiding an uber-like situation for workers) but not with how you do it. It's not the same ethical / philosophical stance as one who considers other ethical matters than software freedom out of scope (and both stances are actually not incompatible).

skybrian 1 hour ago | parent

> Freedom for users, not just programmers. Source code access means little if you can’t read it. Real software freedom has to include usability, accessibility, documentation, and support in the languages people actually speak.

Programming has gotten much more accessible with LLMs. This will eventually result in more user freedom in practice, once forking free software becomes the norm for end users. But custom software needs to be managed, so we will need hosting services and software installers that make finding, downloading, and customizing apps easy.

za_creature 1 hour ago | parent

And running marathons has gotten much more accessible with automobiles.

I'm not really sure what your other point was. There's no universe in which a LLM can somehow correctly fork a project for a different purpose but somehow still needs help in hosting, publishing, building an installer or a ui to do so.

skybrian 30 minutes ago | parent

Sometimes the software already works well for you, but you want to make a small change, perhaps adding a feature.

Here is some software I use that supports this:

https://blog.exe.dev/customizing-shelley

It’s a coding agent, but the same thing could work for other software.

hungryhobbit 1 hour ago | parent

>The full case against LLMs — how they’re built on unconsented labor, sold through hype, and coercively pushed onto workers — deserves its own post, which I’ll link here once I publish it.

I don't dispute that the frontier LLM companies stole vast amounts of intellectual property ... like many orders of magnitude more IP than people who are spending years in jail for piracy. That's indisputable.

But when you start equating piracy (I'm reading your book without paying for it) to SLAVERY (enforced labor) ... that's just so completely ridiculous that I find it difficult to take anything this guy writes seriously.

conartist6 1 hour ago | parent

Well they are asking us to extrapolate.

When we build something for our livelihood, they take it, tell people they made it, and that we only deserve the table scraps.

They say eventually we will thank them for their handouts and stop desiring freedom or respect or rights

jenadine 44 minutes ago | parent

> But when you start equating piracy (...) to SLAVERY

They never equate it. Not even comparing it.

They just give an example of something presumably almost everyone agrees is immoral as a thought experiment.

Ungh 42 minutes ago | parent

Piracy is OK as it's purely consumption. This is not piracy. It's something much worse. It's producing derivative work. It's statistical plagiarism.

It's not stealing work that is done, it is stealing work that is to be done.

jonhohle 8 minutes ago | parent

In some cases it’s not even probability, it just _is_ someone else’s work with the copyright removed.

didgetmaster 1 hour ago | parent

The author is clearly against AI models that are trained on data produced by people without their consent. Yet the whole free software movement is built on the notion that proprietary software is unethical and any attempts to protect it (and other content like movies and music) using DRM or other mechanisms are wrong.

Does anyone else see this as a contradiction?

mod50ack 1 hour ago | parent

Well, it's not necessarily a contradiction, as the copyright protection and licensing aspects are separate. They don't support what they see as copyright infringement, but they also don't think that copy-protection schemes are good for the user, since they also prevent legitimate uses under the law. Also note that the position of the FSF et al. is that there's no reason that art (I mean this in the traditional sense of art: books, music, movies, etc.) can't be proprietary, but that programs are different.

whartung 1 hour ago | parent

Not necessarily, becase the FSM is not about "freeing" software. Its about "free" software. They're not cracking DRM. They're not trying to pirate other software.

Rather they're arguing that software should be free, they work on free software, and then promote their free software over non-free software.

Basically, everyone involved in the FSM is consenting.

With AI IP scraping, that's not so much necessarily the case.

fpaq 1 hour ago | parent

> [...] trained on data produced by people without their consent. Yet the whole free software movement is built on [...]

consent. The whole free software movement is built on consent. For the most part, that consent is conditional - like requiring that you pay it forward (GPL), or at least mention who the author is (MIT).

interroboink 1 hour ago | parent

I think I see what you're saying, but no, I don't think it's a contradiction.

I think the worry from the "free software movement" side is that someone consentually shares some code, then a company takes it, profits from it, but "locks it down" so their additions are not likewise shared. So basically the company is freeloading on what others produced, taking but not giving back — that's what people frown upon.

Likewise, training on data without people's consent is also a type of freeloading, and is frowned upon in a similar fashion. Note that this happens with humans, too: if an artist takes too-direct "inspiration" from another without getting credit, they are called out.

I suppose there are some more absolutist stances, like "abolish copyright" (rather than the milder "abolish freeloading" described above) which would argue against DRM, etc. of any kind, full stop. And, if such a world ever came to pass, and those people felt that their data (artwork, code, etc) should not be available for AI training, that would perhaps be a contradiction, yes.

armchairhacker 1 hour ago | parent

Should GNU not accept contributions from Mac users, since Macs have been built from child slavery? https://www.freedomunited.org/news/apple-child-labor-lawsuit...

tourmalinetaco 1 hour ago | parent

Honestly? It would be funny for a popular project to do this. Code quality would likely improve as well.

jraph 23 minutes ago | parent

Well, it's highly unusual for me to defend the mac, but I guess we'd be all cooked really, because i think horrible working conditions in mines concerns any computer hardware, and that's true for many other things as well. It's not specifically Apple. IIUC, your link seems to be about lawsuits against false claims from Apple (which is extra bad, of course, but others are not saints).

So, it's everyone's devices really.

Here's how I would resolve it: it is a real concern. We should fight against it, and maybe also work on reducing our systemic dependency on computers, use hardware as long as possible, limit the amount of hardware, and encourage reuse (and recycling when everything else fails).

But for now computers are more omnipresent than ever anyway so users having control over their computing and computers is also more important than ever. It's still a fight worth fighting despite software basically depending on horrible labor conditions. (And btw, software already depending on horrible labor conditions is not an excuse to get even worse)

timw4mail 1 hour ago | parent

Do you really want to die on that hill, or do you want to take a valid contribution that fits in with the existing project?

I've never understood why political beliefs should matter for code, unless it actually affects the code in a destructive way.

123ahgd 1 hour ago | parent

No, we take the hill and live on it while ANT will crash tomorrow.

throwaway81523 1 hour ago | parent

Unlike open source, Free Software (capitalized) was intended from its inception a political movement, so of course politics matters to it. Which way the politics should matter is of course a valid topic of discussion.

timw4mail 52 minutes ago | parent

Yes, but there is wisdom in knowing which battles to fight, and which issues to let go. Ultimately, this up to the owner of the project, of course.

jenadine 42 minutes ago | parent

And this is, to my understanding, the point of the article.

untilted 1 hour ago | parent

Relevant comment from Stefan Monnier (former emacs maintainer) on emacs-devel:

> The issue I have with this is that it moves the goal from "defend Free Software" to "defend against generative AI". The Free Software movement's goals are largely aligned with many other social movements, yet to avoid fragmenting our community, the FSF has been very careful to try and stick to software freedom (and let individual members combine this with any other issue they like). I'd rather leave the fight against slop to other groups, even if there might be a lot of overlap between that group and ours.

https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2026-10/msg00...

123ahgd 1 hour ago | parent

The number of business shills in the comments here herding their open source slaves back into the enclosure is funny.

throwfaraway135 1 hour ago | parent

AI(local) is the feature of OS, when it's powerful enough to create your Windows and Word your Photoshop and Chrome then software will be truly free.

lrvick 1 hour ago | parent

Local AI can already do all of those things. I build operating systems and compilers using only consumer GPUs in my garage.

iFreilicht 44 minutes ago | parent

Which models do you recommend running? What amount of RAM do your GPUs have?

k__ 36 minutes ago | parent

Wouldn't most, if not all, those issues go away if AI generated code is always AGPL?

BarryMilo 25 minutes ago | parent

They also go away if capitalism is abolished, or if gravity ceases to function. What's your point?

mpvjs 24 minutes ago | parent

This does not make sense to me. Does the author use money? Is the author remotely aware of the way money is generated and multiplied? Yet once in circulation it can be used for totally honest transactions. Same with code, with the important distinction that code is not inherently a scam. So code should be cut more slack than money. Code is not evil, its use may be. If bad person curiously donates correct code, I keep it.

After the code of conduct , do we want a moral certification for code contributors? You do know where this mindset is leading, don't you?

aaroninsf 7 minutes ago | parent

I agree with the premise that the crux of the issue is consent, the movement is political, and the concerns largely of moral and political philosophy.

From that frame and on its own terms, there is a specific mechanism to context the conclusions and their moral authority: the dimension of where individual liberty (and hence consent) collides with the interests of the body politic and the society at large.

We can imagine the arguments that follow without needing to advocate for them: if you are a good faith accelerationist, the problem with this position is not that it is wrong on its own terms and given its assumed priors,

it's one of the moral foundation. The best interests of society may reasonably be argued to supersede the interests of the individual.

Whether one agrees with that premise generally, or with respect to AI accelerationism, or the ethics of building and using LLMs as we know them, or not, is a different question than the author addresses.

IMO the author's concern is premature. Or, alternately, assumes that this foundational question has an obvious or settled answer.

It does not.

Like it, or not, modern societies do in every dimension—legal, political, ethical—presume that the interests of the commons, of society, of the body politic itself, of the state, do in many places supersede those of individuals.

Libertarians disagree of course: and when they formulate and inhabit their own state, well, they shall be free to operate it on their own terms.

Until then and for the rest of us: the prior art here is against this position, at least the degree you believe one takes seriously that, variously, we are headed into a singularity from which various relatively utopian or post-scarcity outcomes may emerge; or, alternately, that the dystopian reality of a not just dead but actively hostile internet requires one deploy whatever tools are available and capable to survive it. (And the only tool we have to understand and defend against bad AI is good AI.)

nekusar 5 minutes ago | parent

FLOSS is about human rights pertaining to software, and not some mythical 'software rights'.

The fact the FSF does not understand this (or chooses to be oblivious) is why I quit donations to them.