28 points cdrnsf 1 hour ago 10 comments

add-sub-mul-div 1 hour ago | parent

"Evolving" labor from skilled individuals into fungible operators of AI is a huge win for management that doesn't take the form of unemployment.

cdrnsf 53 minutes ago | parent

Huge wins for management are typically huge losses for everyone else.

dingaling911 22 minutes ago | parent

Fungible operators of AI cannot be a valid perspective.

Otherwise managers would be fungible.

Actually, the same skills that make great managers make great AI orchestrators.

htrp 1 hour ago | parent

Isn't this just industrialization, taking skilled artisan work and turning it into repeatable smaller tasks?

borzi 45 minutes ago | parent

AI is doing the literal opposite though, this is why the whole argument falls flat. I am now doing bigger tasks and carry more responsibility than I ever did. The repetitive tasks are automated in a couple minutes.

aurareturn 18 minutes ago | parent

The skilled will become even more valuable.

There were people who managed factory lines, worked on factory line engineering, built tools around factory line, etc.

Then there were car sales men, car dealership owners, contractors who built the car dealership buildings, marketing people who marketed the cars, etc.

The economy grew because the factory line made it more efficient to transport from point A to point B and better harness energy to move goods.

aurareturn 16 minutes ago | parent

The duality of AI opinions.

The same people are often saying how AI is going to take over all our work and no one will have a job, but these same people will also say AI isn't intelligence, it has no moat, it has no viable business model, it has hit a wall, etc.

add-sub-mul-div 6 minutes ago | parent

Those aren't incompatible views. We could end up with subpar AI customer service etc. that never reaches AGI, but it's still what our future is and displaces a lot of labor.

And "no viable business model" for the majority of AI companies doesn't mean that there couldn't be a collapse into a small number of ever consolidating, ever enshittifying winning players, like with streaming for example.

zrn900 5 minutes ago | parent

This is destructive to the civilization and it must be banned: They are literally using knowledge professions - lawyers, scientists, doctors etc - to train AI with gig work and then both causing them to get laid off and also cutting what the gig work pays.

This is literally decimating the educated workforce that human science and technology relies on. When this workforce is decimated, there won't be anyone producing the next scientific paper. Or, more likely, there will be too few. Human science and technology will get hampered as a result.