42 points Brajeshwar 4 hours ago 7 comments

nkurz 3 hours ago | parent

This was flagged dead, but I vouched to revive it. It seems like a decent overview article of a couple recent papers on the potential climate impact of AI. It doesn't feel AI generated itself---which admittedly would be ironic! Even if you think the whole climate narrative is bunk, please explain why in a comment rather than flagging this away. Or am I missing some reason this particular writeup isn't worthy of discussion?

petesergeant 3 hours ago | parent

It's a polemic that doesn't seem to add very much?

A much more interesting post is also on my front-page, which is: https://betterdatacenterproject.com/2026/11/16/how-ai-is-pow...

217 3 hours ago | parent

No it does not. This is just not true at all and is only written to support authors' point of view

There are many way, way more applicable reasons to be disapproving of ai than climate change, this ain't it whatsoever

nkurz 3 hours ago | parent

OK, that's a start. Is this because the studies are wrong and increased use of AI isn't actually going to dramatically increase fossil fuel usage, or because increased fossil fuel consumption isn't actually something that we should worry about?

I'm sure there are arguments for both of these (clean energy will quickly replace the dirty initial sources/why worry about decadal scale global warming in the face of FOOM?) but it would help if you actually made some arguments rather than just gesturing.

isodev 3 hours ago | parent

I think as a planet (forget about borders and superpowers already) we need to ask ourselves where we want this to go.

Wrecking the little natural resources we have left just to pretend we’ve invented “intelligence” seems rather illogical. We’re still very much just simple “post-industrial barbarians”.

sl0wbrainRot 47 minutes ago | parent

The environment thing was an issue for longer than AI:

https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2023/01/harvard-led-a...

Film industry, video game industry, car industry, air travel industry, iPhone industry, Toys R Us industry... were they worth it?

The "highly educated" YOLO'd it the last 60 years cause they'll be dead. Such an enlightened people all those "knowledge workers" who exploited labor and destroyed the environment.

3C in 50 years is locked in. Get ready for Mad Max as famines, equator becomes a heat bubble around the globe force mass migrations at the last minute since no one will pay attention until the last minute.