YHK - yet another hacker news clone

Now, like then, the only people using it are in enterprises who have to use it because Microsoft are already approved and bureaucracy makes it hard to add new vendors.

To an extent, probably. It was the first serious (post GPT3 for all its flaws) AI assistant, but even so I'm not sure it was ever the default choice because it wasn't until after ChatGPT got released that AI capabilities started getting mainstream awareness.

Then ofc Cursor took off, but even then normie coders were AI-sceptical or mostly aware through ChatGPT.

Devin was only ever hype.

I still use Copilot (I've been a subscriber since first available) but in concert with ChatGPT/Codex and Cursor & Warp, so it tends to take a backseat.

I would expect most usage of it to be via VSCode until recently.

So perhaps it was always a secondary choice (despite being the pilot) to the trailblazers like Cursor and Claude Code but it has an important place in history and as a monthly subscription it's one of the best value ones so still worth looking at.

We still use it. Its integration in VSCode makes it very easy to use. We can select which model to use, and Claude’s are the best in my opinion.

It has the best integration with Visual Studio, and it is incredible value for money on the $10/mo plan. I used it for all my legacy WinForms app work.

GitHub Copilot is the only AI we’re allowed to use where I work.

I don’t use it heavily. I had to turn off the auto-suggestions, because they were almost always wrong, and the hijack the tab key, which makes writing my hand painful (having to hit escape before every tab). I tried looking for a way to change the keybinding a year ago, but it didn’t seem possible.

I will occasionally use the Ask sidebar to see if it gives me some good options or for a quick syntax lookup. That’s about it.

It got Agent mode recently, which it defaults to. When this first happened, I went to ask a question and the agent just started doing stuff and destroyed my code in a way that undo didn’t fix. I had to go back to the commit history and make some manual changes to get back to where I was. I never used the agent again.

There has been some talk about getting Claude Code, but the problem is that it takes so long to make these enterprise deals and get something rolled out, that there is something new by the time we get the last new thing deployed. The pace of evolution in this space is faster than the enterprise moves.

I can only assume that when the next model releases, people will say the current Claude Code isn’t very good… so I’m probably not missing much in real terms. It kind of reminds me of video game graphics. The bleeding edge of the current-gen is always talked about as if its photo realistic and so amazing… then looking back at the same game 10 years later, and it looks like trash compared to the new bleeding edge. So maybe it’s not worth getting so worked up.

its my main platform here - claude / codex and everything else context windows and tooling are not up to speed for me and I cant afford API

for 50$ a month for 1500 requests - I use up the entire weeks worth of context for the other platforms in a couple hours with what im coding its annoying as hell and thats if they are working properly setup properly

I currently prefer GitHub Copilot Pro to Claude Code, Cursor, Codex, and OpenCode for my current role and codebase. Staff Engineer in a midsized professional engineering organization. Using Agent mode with latest OpenAI and Anthropic models. Backend TypeScript maintaining established codebases. Not being constrained by management. It’s not a perfect tool but it has advanced significantly since early releases.

We started with GitHub Copilot, but it was largely replaced by Claude Code. The major benefit was that Claude could execute scripts and Copilot could not. That might have just been the way my organization configured it though.

It's not as bad with gemeni and claude in combiniation with skills.