YHK - yet another hacker news clone

6 points argee 2 hours ago 12 comments

Today I noticed the inclusion of emojis in Craigslist's listings/categories: https://www.craigslist.org/area/sfbay.

Now, Craigslist, as a legacy of the 1990s web, has for a long time stubbornly maintained its minimalist style, to the point where several "modern" startups have popped up to try and offer Craigslist-like services to new generations.

So why this change? And what's with the timing? It's coinciding with the wanton proliferation of emojis everywhere courtesy of everyone's favorite GPT. At a time where people are beginning to feel emoji fatigue, Craigslist, of all places, has decided to put them front and center.

Has Craigslist succumbed to the modern algorithmic context of competing for attention? Is this a small concession so they can largely keep their legacy look while still participating in the zeitgeist?

When and with what intention was this emoji introduction initiated?

And most importantly, how do you feel about the entire thing?

dieselgate 2 hours ago | parent

Interesting, it even uses the clippy emoji for resumes!

I think OP is reading into it too much , it seems like a minor embellishment and I never personally correlated emojis with LLMs.

argee 2 hours ago | parent

I wouldn't find it remarkable anywhere else, but Craigslist has built a reputation on not doing this kind of thing.

Grombobulous 1 hour ago | parent

I wouldn't say so.

I would say it's actually exactly the kind of thing they would do - stick with plain text over things that load slower like images.

Emojis are great for that, they're plain unicode text!

argee 1 hour ago | parent

So, why now? Emojis have existed for a while, haven't they? Whereas Craigslist has been using images up until now (at least for the top nav items).

Gualdrapo 1 hour ago | parent

Yup, the association with LLMs is a bit odd, since there's emojis everywhere in mainstream digital comunication way before the big hit of the ai stuff.

Without seeing how it looked before I think this just gives a little bit more of clue about what each category is about. They are still being used sparsely.

The only thing where it irks me to find emojis is in cli apps. They use to not be the same character width as the monofont I use so they either look chopped or they displace their nearing text.

nightpool 2 hours ago | parent

Based on https://web.archive.org/web/20260618001349/https://washingto... and https://web.archive.org/web/20260621034150/https://washingto..., it seems like they were added at some point between the 18th and the 21st. I definitely think it helps navigating the site, and it's a nice compromise between Craigslist's text-first style and a nod towards usability.

argee 1 hour ago | parent

Nice sleuthing! So it's quite a recent change. It stands out to me that the items up top (faves, acct, etc.) which already had icons also got emojified.

Prior to that, they had already introduced emojis to draw attention to their Craigslist charitable fund: that probably made this a much easier decision.

xnx 1 hour ago | parent

I like it.

Good user experience isn't about dogmatically sticking to "text only", but about making a useful, understandable, navigable site.

Emojis seem to help section the dozens of links on the homepage without adding unnecessary visual distraction or page payload.

argee 1 hour ago | parent

> unnecessary visual distraction

I think I personally see emojis used in this manner as unnecessary visual distraction, because it detracts from whatever self-consistent design system you had going on (when used for high visibility items like front page headings). Emojis don't even render the same on every platform, so its a move that dilutes your design language.

Even if it's a useful visual guide, I would wager nine times out of ten you'd be better off with a self-consistent icon set...depending on what you're going for, of course.

OkayPhysicist 41 minutes ago | parent

The page uses 'font-family: sans-serif'. They've already given up on any control over what the page looks like. They leave it up to the browser, which, IMO, more sites should do.

xnx 27 minutes ago | parent

Sites having individual "design language" is part of the problem that got us to the current balkanized web.

comrade1234 1 hour ago | parent

Would have been nice when they had casual encounters - eggplant, water droplets, tongue peach.